The Creation of Tolerance, One Preschooler at a Time.

by Amber on October 5, 2011

in Parenting

We were sitting on the couch together, bowl of cereal in hand, channel surfing on a Saturday morning. I was in search of a cartoon that would entertain a four-year-old boy but wouldn’t send me to the kitchen to hide all the pointy objects before a lisping cartoon animal broke out in an obnoxiously catchy and repetitive tune. (Lisping cartoon animals are the leading cause of parental self-injury, you know.)

I stopped on a relatively innocuous Disney cartoon and turned to him for approval.

“I don’t like this cartoon, Mom. I don’t want to watch shows with brown people.”

My son is very precocious. I’m not sure I can recall a time he wasn’t speaking in full sentences and he never hesitates to say exactly what is on his mind. He once announced during dinner at a family reunion that my grandmother was a girl and therefore had a vagina, and I have learned the hard way never to ask him if he has to go to the bathroom in public where we can be overheard. His high volume and consistent answer? “There’s no pee in my wiener, Mom!”

I have grown accustomed to the mortifying “kids say the darnedest things” moments we all suffer as parents, but I have never felt embarrassment like what I felt in that room, in that moment, just the two of us.

I switched off the television and turned to face him. “Why don’t you like shows with brown people, buddy?”

“Because…brown people are mean, Mom.”

“Being mean has nothing to do with skin color, son. Why would you think that?”

We talked at length that morning. He had recently begun pre-school and he told me about the boy in his class, the brown boy who made him eat dirt who sometimes pushed him. This was my son’s first experience with two things—bullying and children outside of his own race—and they had become linked in his mind.

We talked about bullying and how to cope. We talked about new phases in life and new environments and we talked about brown people and white people and yellow people and how none of it really mattered. Physical appearance does not dictate a person’s character. I impressed that upon him in as many ways as I could, phrasing and rephrasing it. In the end he nodded his head, assured me he understood, and ran up the stairs to play in his room. I took our cereal bowls to the sink and then sat down at the kitchen table feeling like I had failed my son.

Success in parenthood is something that we all must personally define. If you asked a group of parents for their definition of a good mother or father, I am sure you would get a wide variety of answers. For me a major criteria that must be met, a quality that must be instilled in my children as adults in order for me to consider my job as a mother as one well done, is to raise tolerant, accepting, and open-minded individuals.

In a society that openly boos when a gay soldier poses a question during a political debate, where simply being a part of a certain religion qualifies you as a terrorist in the eyes of many, where an American citizen can be stopped and questioned because he or she doesn’t look like they’re from around here, how can my voice be the voice of reason to my child? The answer to that is clear to me now. My voice must be the loudest and I’m going to have to talk pretty loudly (and often) to drown out all the hate in the world.

Racists aren’t born, they are created. I have never been as certain of that as I am after this innocent interaction with my son. I cannot stop the evil that exists in the world I must raise my children in, but one day I hope to release into society two people who will never add their voice to a chorus of hatred, who will instead join me in drowning out the ignorance and intolerance.

It’s never too early to teach your child to love, to accept, to forgive. After all, it’s what they do best.

Amber Doty is the managing editor of Go Mighty, as well as a slightly eccentric wife and mother of two. Her interests include eating meals she had no hand in preparing, making formerly professional business meetings awkward, and perfecting the emotional outburst.  One day she hopes to travel to all seven continents, but for now she lives in North Carolina happily equidistant from the mountains and the beach. You can read more from Amber on her blog, The Daily Doty.

Pamela Schulz October 5, 2011 at 7:51 am

Two things are clear from this post. YOU are a great mother and YOUR mother raised you well!! LUP

Christina October 5, 2011 at 8:25 am

I needed this post. I had no idea how to handle these kinds of comments and questions as they come up. I am happy to have your article for a model.
Good job!

Amber October 9, 2011 at 9:16 pm

Thanks, Christina! It’s such a difficult subject to broach with children and it’s definitely one I would never have guessed I’d be addressing at the age of four, but after that moment I knew it was important to start talking about it. Like, NOW.

Good luck with your talks!

jess October 5, 2011 at 8:26 am

Isn’t it amazing how a kids can take away your breath? My son complained that I wasn’t letting him watch a certain TV show because the cast was primarily African American, when in reality the show was much too old for him and had nothing to do with race. But I felt like he had kicked me in the stomach. I explained my reasons for him not watching the show and how it had nothing to do with the color of the actors skin, but it has made me very aware of how I am setting the tone for his life.

Ashley October 5, 2011 at 8:32 am

I’m glad you addressed it – it’s an intimidating topic and easy to pretend will somehow work itself out so we don’t have to deal with the discomfort. I’m really glad CGG is publishing this, as well.

Unsolicited suggestion – and I’m not saying I think you were – please don’t go down the “colorblind” path when teaching your son about race. Maybe I’m preaching to the choir, and if so, please forgive me. Being colorblind (in terms of race) is impossible, at least in the U.S., and in my opinion, that strategy backfires and stalls progress.

Amber October 5, 2011 at 8:45 am

I’m really glad you brought up the issue of teaching him to be “colorblind” and I don’t want to turn this comment into a novel, but I wanted to say I agree with and understand what you are saying. It’s something I didn’t grasp until adulthood, until my mid-twenties actually.
I think for now I am talking out the issues with him in an age appropriate way. As he grows I expect our conversations to be deeper if that makes sense.

Ashley October 5, 2011 at 9:27 am

I’m 33 and I think I really began learning about the problems with trying to be colorblind in the last few years. I’ve always been drawn to the topic of race and was surprised that it hadn’t occurred to me that acting colorblind doesn’t help, it actually hurts. I think it sunk in, bit by bit – I mean, it still is. It’s not like I can say I am free of all my hangups and mistakes, but I can say that I’m trying really hard to learn and improve. Having a forum like this to discuss things like race/racism/intolerance/privilege is SO important. It’s hard enough to talk about these things in the first place so having a “safe space” and someone to introduce the topic means a lot. So, thanks to you & CGG.

That does make sense (deeper conversations later). Regardless of what belief or lifeview you’re hoping to instill, you have to teach to them at their level. Not everyone can have kindergartners who can read & understand Unpacking the Invisible BackPack . . . *ahem* . . . ;) Just kidding!

Amy October 5, 2011 at 8:46 am

I could not agree more. Bravo.

Rachel October 5, 2011 at 11:05 am

You are an AWESOME mom. Seriously.

And on a side note, if you’re looking for music that will entertain your son & teach him some great lessons about friendship, etc., but won’t make you want to stab your own eardrums with a broken pencil, check out the album Hopes & Dreams by Tony Martirano. You can get it on iTunes. I’m not ashamed to admit, I love it and even downloaded the album to my ipod just for my own listening pleasure.

Amber October 9, 2011 at 9:17 pm

I’ll have to check that out, Rachel. The Kids channel on Pandora isn’t doing much for me. Plus, anything is better than the Yo Gabba Gabba brainworms in my head daily.

Jennifer October 5, 2011 at 11:20 am

I know this hurt, but you addressed it in exactly the right manner. You did a good job and you are NOT a failure.

I’ve talked with my kids about race since they were little. We live in an area that, while I wouldn’t call it racially charged, I also wouldn’t call it racially tolerant. Mostly people here are either just so backward that they don’t get it, or they really are just plain old racists and don’t even realize it (or don’t care).

One day my daughter came home from school and one of her classmates told her that he didn’t like Justin Bieber because “he dates a Mexican.” I was so thankful when my daughter said, “Mom that’s just dumb. It doesn’t matter what color you are.” Even though she gets that I still took the time to reinforce with her that being a good person has nothing to do with the color of your skin and everything to do with the quality of your heart.

I just think these conversations need to happen all the time, and we need to continue to raise children that challenge these concepts so that, hopefully, one day they will be broken.

Amber October 9, 2011 at 9:20 pm

I couldn’t agree more. I come from a very small town in the south and it’s still not completely out of line for people to use racial slurs. There was a time when I just cringed, but didn’t speak up. Correcting my elders was something I was brought up not to do, but as a parent now I can’t let things like that slide.
I don’t let anyone use hate speech in front of my children. You are right about challenging the concepts. We have to model that for them.

Robin | Farewell, Stranger October 5, 2011 at 11:29 am

Wow, that would have made me pause too. Good for you for handling it well.

This type of thing hit home for us a while ago too. A friend’s daughter told another friend of ours that she’s too fat to go on the swings. My friend was shocked that her daughter even knew the word “fat” (she’s 3) never mind thought to say that to someone. She must have been exposed to it somewhere, but what a horrifying thing to realize how pervasive these beliefs are in our culture.

Amber October 9, 2011 at 9:22 pm

It’s interesting you bring up the F word, Robin. That is one that I have to remind MYSELF not to use in front of my kids. It’s so easy to use that word to describe myself and equally as easy to put it into their vocabulary.

Allison Zapata October 5, 2011 at 11:34 am

I’m so happy I know you. You are my people ;) and an awesome mom. xo

Julie October 5, 2011 at 12:54 pm

Just beautiful. Thank you for this.

bellawriter October 5, 2011 at 3:44 pm

Truly inspiring. Well done (standing ovation), well done!!

Kara @ June & Bear October 5, 2011 at 10:16 pm

We’ve been wondering when we should approach this topic because our children have been exposed to diversity. We’ve been surprised that June doesn’t even notice the difference in skin color to date. They are just other kids. I’m sure the time will come. Raising open-minded, tolerant children is high on our priority list too.

Erin @ Miss Lifesaver October 6, 2011 at 3:09 pm

This post makes me want to give you a huge hug! I don’t think many people stop to think about how pervasive the covert racism still is in our culture, and therefore, how important it is to have these conversations… especially the young, impressionable ones.

Katie October 7, 2011 at 3:23 pm

Amber, you are truly a wonderful person, and I’m glad that I know you. I try to surround myself with people who are tolerant and loving and open-minded. If I was a mother, I would try to teach my children to do the same. But the fact of the matter is that you cannot keep every tiny bit of hate away at all times. I wish we lived in a world in which we could. I truly do. And despite this fact, you will be successful in raising tolerant, loving, and open-minded children. Because you are passionate and because you are teaching them in the very best way…by example.

January October 7, 2011 at 8:07 pm

You explained it perfectly. I’m always worried when and how I should bring this up with my 3 year old. Our neighbours are ‘brown’ and great friends of ours. He has yet to ‘notice’ but he’s aware of all the different cultures that surround us and in our family (we have a few members that are from all over the globe which is very cool but also may be why he’s yet to question it?) It seems such a complicated subject for a such young minds but I absolutely love how you handled it.

Amber October 9, 2011 at 9:23 pm

Thanks, January. Until this happened I didn’t know that my son had noticed the difference in races either. It was kind of a shock to me to hear him say that.

ASuburbanLife October 11, 2011 at 12:10 am

What a great post, thank you for writing this!

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: